"WHAT IS JUSTICE: A QUEST TO UNDERSTAND THE TRUTH" By T. Ajay Shankar

Posted by Matt McAvoy on Saturday, November 11, 2017 Under: Book Reviews




REVIEW PUBLISHED AT AUTHOR’S REQUEST.

I had half an hour or so to spare, so I thought I’d peruse “What is Justice?”, as one with a background and interest in this field.  It was sent to me as a short book, with the tagline “A Quest to Understand the Truth”.  In T. Ajay Shankar’s defence, I feel some of the unpleasant and actually quite rude reviews I’ve seen are a touch unfair, and it does sting a little seeing a fellow author treated to such harsh criticism.  That said, however, unfortunately this is not a “book”, nor can it really call itself a “quest” to understand the truth.

What it is, in fact, is little more than a thesis or dissertation in which Shankar presents every common argument of what defines justice, evaluates it (in the author’s defence, quite fairly), and then subsequently proceeds to dismantle it.  Such examples for discussion include morality, the law, social equality and more, before eventually, and perhaps not unexpectedly, coming to focus on a theological explanation.  I say “unexpectedly” because the piece actually reads more as a monologue or statement; it is as though Shankar has composed a speech and then simply published the paper it was written on.  Again, though, in the author’s defence, the theological argument is not one which is drilled home; Shankar does not present to be an overly religious person, and actually discredits this particular explanation equally, but, still, one does get the impression this remains the focal point of “What is Justice?”  The passionate vitriol throughout, and the continuous addressing of the readers as “my wise men” does become a touch distracting, and seems to increase in its zeal to a point where the language becomes almost incoherent.  English is clearly not the author’s first language, and it is broken to a sufficient level to render Shankar’s point, when it comes, almost indiscernible.

All this regardless, I do not consider “What is Justice?” to be a moot work or lost cause, as some might suggest.  I definitely wouldn’t call it a story, but I still admire Shankar for the passion and consideration put into the work.  I feel the book definitely needs a pretty hard copy-edit for the English language and formatting, including ruthless cuts of the second person (reader) reference.  I also think it would be much more enjoyable delivered in a creative way – perhaps as a fable, being imparted to a crowd by the principle, or by a lawyer in court; maybe this could encourage Shankar to write an anthology of his theses for publication, which I would actually be very interested to see.

In : Book Reviews 


Tags: ajay-shankar  justice  criminal-justice  non-fiction 
LATEST BOOK REVIEWS:

***
Satire


****
Comedy


****
Comedy


****
Comedy


****
Fantasy


*****
Self Improvement


****
Action


****
Short Stories


***
Historical Fiction


*****
Children's


*****
Drama


****
Drama


*****
Political Thriller


***
Short Stories


****
Poetry


****
Historical Fiction


***
Autobiography


****
Philosophy


****
Thriller


****
YA / Fantasy


****
Children's


***
Suspense/Thriller


***
Sci-Fi/Fantasy


***
Adventure


****
Horror


****
Short Stories


****
Crime Drama


*****
Poetry


*****
Children's


****
Documentary


****
Historical Thriller


****
Fantasy


****
Horror


***
Comedy


***
Horror


*****
Comedy-Drama


*****
Historical Fiction


*****
War Memoir


****
Short Stories


*****
War Memoir


****
Real Life


*****
Comedy-Drama


***
Fantasy


****
Poetry


*****
Short Stories


***
Fantasy


*****
Business


***
Historical Fiction


***
Children's


*****
Poetry


***
Historical Fiction


*****
Science


***
Poetry


*****
Short Stories


*****
Self-Help


****
Fantasy


****
Self-Help


****
Short Stories


*****
Fantasy


***
Drama


****
Children's


****
Comedy


****
Biography


****
Short Stories


***
Supernatural


**
Documentary


****
Historical Fantasy


*****
Documentary


***½
Thriller


***
Non-Fiction


***
Crime Thriller

Tags

a-scholte abortion abuse action addiction afterlife ajay-shankar alejandro-de-gutierre alexander-the-great alphabet american-history ancient ancient-history animal-abuse animal-rescue animal-welfare anthology anthony-michaelides anthony-simola anti-hero anxiety arabian artificial-intelligence atlantis australia autobiography bereavement biography bittersweet bizarre blind bo-wu boats books borneo brian-kindall british business catholic cats chad-lee-erway childhood children's christ christianity christina-williams christopher-adam clinchandhill clint-thurmon coffee-break cognitive collection colonialism comedy corporate-crime cory-barclay coup creatures crime criminal-justice crm cruelty cynical dark data data-analytics david-donachie david-grad david-lee-fish demons detective diary dictatorship diet disability dog-rescue dogs drama drugs dwayne-gill dystopian ea-minin earthquake ecological educational egyptian emergency emmanuella-hristova emotional empire environmental espionage faith fallacious-rose family fantasy fiction fiona-green flash-fiction frances-bloom friendship frontier funny futuristic george-dalrymple george-koloukis glyn-haynie gm-o'connor god gods gory health health-and-fitness heartbreaking heather-beal henry-woodiss historical historical-fiction history holistic horror illustrated immigrants international internet ira irish j-kariuki jacinta-jade jennifer-macaire jesus jill-kearney john-simpson journal jungle justice ka-cummins kyla-ross lady-byrd laura-eckert laura-hergane laura-koerber legendary leigh-holland life lin-wilder lindsay-mccall lindsey-mccall lorna-brown loss lynne-renoir maria-luisa-lang marine-life martin-freznell mathematics matt-nagin medical medical-drama medieval melodrama memoir mermaids michael-a.-greco michael-irwin military mind mjl-evans monologue myrtle-brooks mystery mythical natural-disaster navy new-jersey new-york nick-dream non-fiction norman-aj-berisford northern-ireland novella nutrition observations oppression otherworld outback pablo-palazuelo persia personal-development pharaoh philosophy pirates platoon poetry political political-thriller prison pro-life psychology purgatory race rae-louise rainforest reading real-life redemption reference regime relationship religion religious remorse revolutionary richard-bunning richard-hacker robert-kingett roman romania rural sailing sailors satire sci-fi science seafaring self-confidence self-help sexual sexual-harassment short-stories sigal-haber sitcom slavery slice-of-life society sociopath soldier special-forces sports spy-thriller stage-fright stan-skrabut steve-bassett study superhero supernatural superstition surreal swashbuckling teamwork technology teen the-troubles theodor theological thriller time-travel tomi-farrell torture tough-guy tragedy true-story tv-shows undersea vampire venezuela ventskevitch veteran vietnam vietnam-war vigilante vince-rockston violent walt-sautter war war-memoir weight-loss well-being werewolf western wildlife yorkshire young-adult
Website designed and created by MJV SERVICES, UNITED KINGDOM 2016 - all rights reserved.
*The author has established copyright for all work featured on this website.